logo
twitterbirdfacebookpinterest
  • MOVIE REVIEWS
  • BLU-RAY & DVD REVIEWS
  • PODCASTS
  • FEATURES
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT US



orphanORPHAN
(R)
* (out of 5)

July 24, 2009

STARRING
Vera Farmiga as KATE COLEMAN
Peter Sarsgaard as JOHN COLEMAN
Isabelle Furman as ESTHER
CCH Pounder as SISTER ABIGAIL
Jimmy Bennett as DANIEL COLEMAN
Margo Martindale as DR. BROWNING
Aryana Engineer as MAX COLEMAN

Studio: Warner Bros.

Directed by: Jaume Collet-Serra

BY KEVIN CARR

Listen to Kevin’s radio review…




On a certain level, I was kind of looking forward to seeing “Orphan.” After all, I am a long-time horror movie buff, and all those creepy kid movies from the 70s (e.g., “The Omen” and “The Exorcist”) really freaked me out.

Count me disappointment, befuddled and totally flabbergasted when I finally saw the film.

“Orphan” tells the story of Kate and John Coleman (Vera Farmiga and Peter Sarsgaard), who lost a baby at delivery and now want to adopt a child. They find Esther (Isabelle Furman), a seemingly brilliant and beautiful little nine-year-old Russian girl. However, when they bring Esther home, she starts to terrorize the Coleman’s other two children, commits a series of violent acts and pits Kate and John against each other.

There is so much wrong with this film that I am almost overwhelmed. On the surface, “Orphan” looks like it might be pretty good. But it’s not even an effective horror movie. Instead, it’s the cinematic equivalent of a mockingbird. It sounds like a scary film, but it really isn’t.

There’s some gore and plenty of violence, but the suspense is awkward and misaligned. Director Jaume Collet-Serra thinks he’s so clever by trying to get you to jump at nothing, building the music to reveal that no one is around the corner or behind camera. However, when he tries this the fifth, sixth and even the seventh time, the only surprise is that Collet-Serra doesn’t think the audience has actually caught on yet.

The script is so deliberately written to keep the secret of this little girl that it becomes completely unbelievable. In order to do this, the main characters are so stupid (and that’s really saying something for a genre that revels in stupid characters to propel the thrill) that I found myself rooting against them. After all, if their actions are so moronic that they put themselves in needless danger, why should I get behind them.

Case in point, well into the film, Kate is convinced that Esther is evil. Yet she still lets the girl have the run of the house, complete and total access to every makeshift weapon imaginable and unrestricted interaction with her other kids. Moreover, in one scene, she asks both her children if Esther has done anything inappropriate or dangerous. The kids cower and look terrified as they lie (because Esther threatens them to keep quiet), and Kate doesn’t pick up on this. Is she’s such a bad parent that she can’t catch her kids in a lie, does she even deserve to be saved?

There is a certain payoff in this film, which is revealed in the last twenty minutes. A critic colleague of mine confided in me that he laughed hysterically (which wasn’t the intended response, of course) as the ending of the film played out. I admitted to him that I would have laughed if the movie hadn’t already sucked my soul from my body.

I give Vera Farmiga and Peter Sarsgaard credit for keeping a straight face while acting in this film. In fact, their performances are pretty decent, considering what a mess the movie is. They should have checked out director Jaume Collet-Serra’s resume first, though. If they had known this was the hack who gave us 2005’s stinker “House of Wax,” they might have dodged this bullet.

Posted in Movie Reviews | Tags: Aryana Engineer, CCH Pounder, Isabelle Furman, Jaume Collet-Serra, Jimmy Bennett, Margo Martindale, Orphan, Peter Sarsgaard, Vera Farmiga |
« ‘300: The Complete Experience’ Blu-ray Review
‘The Ugly Truth’ Movie Review »

Leave a comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search by Month

Buy 13 TURNS, Kevin Carr’s latest horror anthology!

Only $2.99 in the Kindle store.

Buy UNDERBRUSH, Kevin Carr’s latest technothriller!

Only $2.99 in the Kindle store.

Buy FIVE NIGHTS IN VEGAS, Elizabeth Stokes’ latest romance!

Only $2.99 in the Kindle store.

Recent Reviews

  • ‘Pan’ Blu-ray Review
  • ‘Star Wars: The Force Awakens’ Movie Review
  • ‘The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies – Extended Edition’ Blu-ray Review
  • ‘The Funhouse Massacre’ Movie Review
  • ‘Spectre’ Movie Review
  • ‘Extraordinary Tales’ Movie Review
  • ‘Bone Tomahawk’ Movie Review
  • ‘San Andreas’ Blu-ray Review
  • ‘Avengers: Age of Ultron’ Blu-ray Review
  • ‘Gravy’ Blu-ray Review
  • ‘The Martian’ Movie Review
  • ‘The Walk’ Movie Review
  • ‘The Bear’ Blu-ray Review
  • ‘Hotel Transylvania 2’ Movie Review
  • ‘The Intern’ Movie Review
  • ‘Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials’ Movie Review
  • ‘Intro to Hitchcock’ at the Gateway Film Center
  • ‘The Legacy’ Blu-ray Review
  • ‘The Editor’ Blu-ray Review
  • ‘Mystery-Science Theater 3000: Volume I’ DVD Review

Copyright 2002-2016.
All rights reserved.

CONTACT US
ADVERTISE
CyberChimps

CyberChimps

CyberChimps ©2019